BJC Blog RSS Feeds
Home arrow Blog arrow Is Church Attendance an Appropriate Criminal Sentence?
Is Church Attendance an Appropriate Criminal Sentence? E-mail
Written by Don Byrd   
Monday, 26 November 2012

The New York Times looks into a controversial Oklahoma judge, who is under fire for sentencing juvenile offenders to church attendance. Most recently, Tyler Alred, a minor charged with vehicular manslaughter was ordered to attend church regularly for 10 years as a part of his probation.

Mr. Alred told the court that he was happy to agree to church attendance and other mandates — including that he finish high school and train as a welder, and shun alcohol, drugs and tobacco for a year. By doing so, he is avoiding a 10-year prison sentence and has a chance to make a fresh start.

But his acquiescence does not change the law, Mr. Kiesel and others pointed out. “Alternative sentencing is something that should be encouraged, but there are many options that don’t violate the Constitution,” Mr. Kiesel said. “A choice of going to prison or to church — that is precisely the type of coercion that the First Amendment seeks to prevent.”

Making a person choose between prison and church would seem to be the ultimate coercion. In addition, Mr. Alred apparently already was a regular church attendant when he committed the offense, a fact Judge Norman confessed he was unaware.

 
 
Louisiana Considers Holy Bible as State Book
Over the years writing this blog, I have seen several state and local governments memorialize the Ten Commandments through monuments, posters and other government displays. But a recent effort in Louisiana is a new (misguided) way to promote Scripture through government: legislators there are...
 
Religious Groups File Brief in Clergy Housing Exemption Appeal
Last year, a federal judge in Wisconsin ruled unconstitutional the tax exemption for clergy's housing costs. The parsonage allowance, Judge Barbara Crabb held, favors religion over non-religion in violation of the First Amendment.  Her surprising decision is being appealed to the 7t...