BJC Blog RSS Feeds
Home arrow Blog arrow Judge Dismisses Murfreesboro Mosque Challenge
Judge Dismisses Murfreesboro Mosque Challenge E-mail
Written by Don Byrd   
Friday, 20 May 2011

In Rutherford County, Tennessee, an attempt to halt the construction of a mosque on the foolish grounds that Islam is not a religion, and that it is inherently a threat, has been dismissed by Judge Robert Corlew. The Tennessean reports:

Corlew said the plaintiffs have to prove an injury different from that suffered by other residents of the county, but denied their claims that their religion made them targets for subjugation under what is known as Shariah law.

He said earlier that the court did not find that Islamic Center of Murfreesboro members adhered to extremist religious ideas.

...[T]here is inadequate evidence in the record which supports this plaintiff’s contention of a casual connection between the teachings of Sharia law and the actions of the county government,” Corlew wrote.

Corlew said that he respected the opinions of the plaintiffs but that the U.S. Constitution has established the right to freedom of religion and tolerance of differing religious beliefs.

Corlew is allowing one claim to proceed: that the planning commission violated open meetings law, but not claims that the commission made an inappropriate decision,  that a mosque represents a threat to the community, or that somehow Islam does not qualify for religious liberty protections under the US Constitution.

 
 
Arizona Senate Passes Changes to RFRA, Sends to Governor
I posted earlier about the Arizona bill making its way through the legislature that would broaden the free exercise protections in the state's Religious Freedom Restoration Act. Among other changes, the bill would allow plaintiffs to bring suit for "potential violations." Here&...
 
Is the Endorsement Test on the Chopping Block?
The Supreme Court's decision earlier this week to take up the issue of legislative prayer for the first time in 30 years leaves many questions about the future of the government prayer balance. Veteran reporter Lyle Deniston considers what this decision likely means in a new essay for Constit...