BJC Blog RSS Feeds
Home arrow Blog arrow 4th Circuit Rejects Challenge to Church-Housing Partnership
4th Circuit Rejects Challenge to Church-Housing Partnership E-mail
Written by Don Byrd   
Tuesday, 28 December 2010

The Washington Post reports on a 4th Circuit decision from last week approving an Arlington County plan to rebuild Clarendon First Baptist Church and situate affordable housing above it. The government will subsidize the mixed-use development, which was challenged by a resident arguing the arrangement violates the separation of church and state.

One of plaintiff Peter Glassman's most interesting arguments - that the proximity of subsidized housing to the church itself creates a religious overtone to the apartments - is taken on directly by the court in its opinion:

This proximity of secular tenants to church property, however, cannot justify an argument that the tenants would be subject to religious indoctrination. The only areas of the building shared by Church members and the tenants were the lobby and the elevator, and these, by their nature, are not places where religious indoctrination would occur. Glassman’s allegation that "requiring" the tenants to see the Church’s steeple somehow violates the Establishment Clause is no more forceful than an argument that his viewing the Church’s steeple from his own home, within a block of the Church, led to unconstitutional indoctrination.

 
 
Arizona Senate Passes Changes to RFRA, Sends to Governor
I posted earlier about the Arizona bill making its way through the legislature that would broaden the free exercise protections in the state's Religious Freedom Restoration Act. Among other changes, the bill would allow plaintiffs to bring suit for "potential violations." Here&...
 
Is the Endorsement Test on the Chopping Block?
The Supreme Court's decision earlier this week to take up the issue of legislative prayer for the first time in 30 years leaves many questions about the future of the government prayer balance. Veteran reporter Lyle Deniston considers what this decision likely means in a new essay for Constit...