Wisconsin Court Denies "Ministerial Exception" for Catholic Teacher Hiring
A Wisconsin Appeals Court has denied an argument by Catholic schools that they are not bound by discrimination laws in hiring teachers, according to the AP.
"A general exemption for teachers in religious schools would be more expansive than warranted when considered in light of the magnitude of the state's interest in the enforcement of anti-discrimination laws," Judge Margaret Vergeront wrote for a unanimous three-judge panel.
...
The diocese said the state has no jurisdiction over Catholic school teachers who carry out the pastoral mission of the church and incorporate Catholic values into their teachings.The court disagreed, saying Ostlund's primary duties did not involve matters of faith. She taught religion, led students in prayer and planned liturgies but her main responsibilities included teaching secular subjects, the court said.